Skip to content

3 of the Craziest Murder Defenses that Actually Worked

Home » Firm News » Criminal Defense » 3 of the Craziest Murder Defenses that Actually Worked

If you or someone you know has been charged with murder, you’re probably wondering how you’ll get out of this mess. If you didn’t commit the crime – or, if you did it in self-defense – you can only pray that your criminal defense lawyer in San Diego can get you off.

There are several typical defenses to murder. Some of them include the following:

  • Lack of Intent – You did not intend to kill or cause great bodily harm to the victim.
  • Lack of Evidence – You didn’t do it and the State has nothing to prove you did.
  • Insanity – You didn’t have the mental capacity to commit the crime.
  • Self-Defense – You were acting in self-defense at the time of the act.

If any of these apply in your case, you can bet your defense lawyer in San Diego will raise it. If they can prove any of these defenses, they’ll be able to get the prosecutor to dismiss the charges against you.

Over the years, prosecutors have seen thousands of cases where these defenses were used. However, they’ve seen their share of cases where strange defenses were raised as well. It’s hard to imagine how attorneys come up with some of these defenses. It’s even harder to imagine that these defenses worked.

Here are three (3) of the strangest murder defenses we’ve ever seen. And, surprisingly, the jury bought the defense in all three of these cases. Hopefully, your San Diego defense attorney won’t have to resort to these types of defenses.

The Twinkie Defense

Back in 1978, a young man named Dan White shot and killed Harvey Milk and George Moscone. He lived in San Francisco and murdered both men in what appeared to be cold blood. White had been depressed leading up to the day he killed these men. He said that he had eaten nothing but Twinkies for several days leading up to the event.

At trial, White’s lawyers argued that he didn’t have the mental capacity to know that what he was doing was wrong. He argued that White had ingested so much sugar over the days prior to the murder that it made him insane. This, coupled with his depression, the lawyer argued, made it impossible him to have the mental capacity to plan a murder.

The jury actually bought his defense. Instead of being sentenced to death, White was convicted only of voluntary manslaughter. The jury found him guilty and sentenced him to eight (8) short years.

The Mirror Defense

This case takes us all the way to Malaysia where a young man was caught red handed dealing drugs. A 27-year old man was found with 166 kilos of marijuana and a bunch of opium on him. He was charged with drug trafficking – a crime that, in Malaysia, was punishable by death by hanging.

There was plenty of evidence against the defendant, including DNA evidence. However, the defendant happened to have a twin. His twin, who shared the exact same DNA as the defendant, claimed that he was the one who had done the crime.

The jury had no idea who was telling the truth. They had two men who had the same DNA and looked exactly the same. They were so confused that they admitted they didn’t know who had committed the crime. Both men were acquitted and set free.

The Matrix Defense

A woman in Ohio decided one day to kill her landlady. She was charged with murder after shooting the woman to death. At trial, her defense lawyer claimed that she believed she was living in the Matrix – just like in the movie.

The defendant claimed that she believed her landlady was part of a conspiracy to brainwash her and then kill her. She said the conspiracy existed in the matrix and that she would be killed in a computer simulation.

The jury believed her story and found her not guilty by reason of insanity.

Contact an Experienced Criminal Defense Lawyer in San Diego

If you’ve been charged with murder in San Diego, you need to call an experienced criminal defense lawyer. Your lawyer will review the evidence against you to see if any defenses apply. Now, they won’t be arguing that you ate too many cupcakes. But they will put a strong defense on in an effort to get your charges reduced or dismissed.

Call San Diego Criminal today and schedule your consultation. You have no waste to time if there are murder charges pending against you. You need a reliable criminal attorney in San Diego if you have any prayer of walking free.

Scroll To Top